Back to Resources

Remember the first time you sold something online? The thrill of that notification ping, the satisfaction of shipping out a package to someone who actually wanted what you were selling? 

Those were simpler times in e-commerce.

Today’s digital marketplace landscape looks like a three-ring circus compared to those early days. With thousands of sellers flooding Amazon daily, Walmart aggressively expanding its third-party marketplace, and TikTok Shop bursting onto the scene with its explosive growth, the game has fundamentally changed.

At Canopy Management, we’ve had front-row seats watching this evolution unfold. After managing over $3.21 billion in revenue for our partners and achieving an average 84% year-over-year profit growth, we’ve developed a sixth sense for what works across these platforms. 

The secret? 

Understanding that each marketplace has its own distinct personality, algorithm quirks, and customer behaviors.

So let’s cut through the noise and break down exactly how to optimize your product listings across the e-commerce trifecta.

Same Game, Different Rulebooks: Core Listing Elements Across Platforms

Amazon, Walmart, and TikTok Shop all require the same basic listing components, but the way you approach each one varies dramatically. It’s like the difference between cooking for a food critic, a hungry teenager, and someone scrolling Instagram for food inspiration – same ingredients, completely different presentations.

Keywords: The Search Visibility Foundation

Amazon: Think of Amazon’s A10 algorithm as the most sophisticated librarian you’ve ever met. It catalogs and categorizes with remarkable precision, but it needs exact terminology to work its magic. We approach Amazon keyword research like digital detectives, using specialized tools to uncover high-volume search terms that your competitors might have missed.

The backend search fields are your secret weapon here. Those 249 bytes of hidden keyword space where you can include synonyms, misspellings, and related terms without cluttering your customer-facing content. We’ve seen conversion rates jump 20-30% from backend optimization alone.

Walmart: Walmart’s approach to keywords is more pragmatic, reflecting its brick-and-mortar origins. Its system heavily emphasizes product attributes as filtering mechanisms. In our testing, we’ve found that Walmart’s algorithm strongly rewards sellers who take the time to complete every relevant product attribute field. It’s like filling out a detailed job application – tedious but absolutely worth the effort.

The platform explicitly warns against keyword repetition and stuffing, focusing more on relevance than volume. Our data shows Walmart shoppers use more direct, value-focused search terms compared to Amazon browsers, so optimize accordingly.

TikTok Shop: If Amazon is a librarian and Walmart is a practical store manager, TikTok Shop is the cool kid who sets trends at school. Traditional keyword strategies get flipped upside down here. While product titles and descriptions still matter, TikTok’s discovery algorithm is far more influenced by engagement signals than direct keyword matching.

Success here requires thinking beyond traditional search terms to include trending hashtags, popular sounds, and phrases that might appear in video captions or spoken content. In our campaigns, we’ve found that strategic hashtag usage combining trending tags (like #TikTokMadeMeBuyIt) with niche-specific ones can increase product discovery by up to 40%.

Product Titles: First Impressions Matter

Amazon: Amazon allows up to 200 characters for titles, but Canopy’s testing consistently shows that front-loading the most important information pays dividends. Despite the generous character limit, we’ve found that titles between 60-80 characters perform best, especially on mobile where longer titles get truncated.

The winning formula typically follows: Brand + Model + Product Type + Key Features (Size/Color/Quantity). Amazon’s strict title guidelines prohibit promotional phrases like “Best Seller” or excessive capitalization – violations we’ve seen trigger algorithmic suppression.

Walmart: Walmart’s title structure recommendations mirror Amazon’s, but with a crucial difference: they actively discourage copying titles directly from other platforms. In our audits of top-performing Walmart listings, we’ve noticed that titles tend to be slightly shorter (50-75 characters) and more straightforward than their Amazon counterparts.

Walmart shoppers appear to respond better to practical, benefit-focused titles rather than feature-heavy ones. It’s a subtle distinction, but one that can significantly impact click-through rates.

TikTok Shop: TikTok Shop titles need to be punchy and instantly communicative. While Amazon and Walmart titles are designed primarily for search algorithms, TikTok titles must catch attention in a fraction of a second as users scroll their feeds.

We’ve had success with titles that lead with a strong benefit statement followed by essential details, using just enough information to clarify what the product is. Think of it as writing a mini-headline rather than a catalog entry.

Product Imagery & Video: The Visual Differentiator

Amazon: Amazon’s main image requirements remain among the strictest in e-commerce. That means a pure white background, professional photography, no text overlays, and the product must occupy at least 85% of the frame. It’s clinical, controlled, and conversion-focused.

The secondary image slots give you room to breathe creatively. In our testing, we’ve found the optimal image sequence is: main product shot, lifestyle/in-use image, key feature close-up, size/scale reference, and comparison chart. Video integration through A+ Content (especially Premium A+) has shown conversion rate increases of 10-15% in our partner accounts.

Walmart: Walmart’s image guidelines closely resemble Amazon’s, though the platform is slightly more flexible on main image composition. We’ve observed that Walmart shoppers respond particularly well to “in situation” lifestyle imagery that shows the product solving real problems.

Unlike Amazon’s self-service A+ Content tools, Walmart’s Rich Media features (like 360-degree spins and enhanced content) often require working with approved third-party providers. This extra hurdle means fewer sellers utilize these features, creating an opportunity for brands willing to invest in standing out.

TikTok Shop: This is where the platforms diverge dramatically. While Amazon and Walmart built their empires on static images with video as a supplementary feature, TikTok Shop inverts this relationship entirely. Here, video isn’t just important – it’s everything.

The most successful TikTok Shop listings in our portfolio leverage:

• Authentic, “raw” product demonstrations
• Creator-style videos that mirror organic TikTok content
• Fast-paced editing with the first 3 seconds designed to stop the scroll
• Clear, immediate problem-solution frameworks
• Trending sounds and effects (properly licensed, of course)

We’ve consistently seen that production value matters far less than authenticity and engagement. A slightly wobbly, handheld demo that feels genuine often outperforms polished studio content.

Enhanced Content: Telling Your Brand Story

Amazon: Through Brand Registry, Amazon offers Basic and Premium A+ Content that essentially transforms your product description into a rich, visual storytelling canvas. Premium A+ (if you qualify) offers interactive hotspots, video integration, and comparison charts that can dramatically improve conversion rates.

We’ve used these features to help partners showcase product origin stories, demonstrate complex features, and create emotional connections that standard bullet points simply can’t achieve. The investment in quality A+ Content typically pays for itself within 1-2 months through increased conversion rates.

Walmart: Walmart’s equivalent is its Rich Media feature, but the implementation process is less straightforward than Amazon’s. While Amazon offers direct self-service tools for A+ Content, Walmart often requires working with approved Connected Content Solution Providers for more advanced below-the-fold enhancements.

Despite this additional complexity, Rich Media provides significant competitive advantages on Walmart, where relatively fewer sellers utilize these features compared to Amazon.

TikTok Shop: TikTok Shop doesn’t offer direct equivalents to A+ Content or Rich Media. Instead, the platform integrates product details directly within the video viewing experience. The focus shifts from static enhanced content to creating engaging video content that functions as both entertainment and product education.

Success here requires thinking like a content creator rather than a traditional marketer. Each video should stand on its own merits as entertaining, useful content first, with product integration feeling natural rather than forced.

The Platform-Specific Secret Sauce

Beyond the core listing elements, each platform offers unique optimization levers that can dramatically impact performance:

Amazon: The Amazon ecosystem offers a mature suite of advanced features for brand owners. Strategic use of Amazon Posts, Brand Story, Sponsored Brand ads, and Amazon Vine can create a comprehensive brand presence that extends far beyond individual product listings.

Walmart: Walmart’s Listing Quality Score (LQS) is the north star metric for optimization. This dashboard provides specific, actionable recommendations across content, pricing, and operational factors. Unlike Amazon, Walmart explicitly factors pricing and shipping speed into search ranking, requiring sellers to maintain competitive offers beyond just listing quality.

TikTok Shop: TikTok’s creator-centric approach demands a fundamentally different optimization mindset. Success hinges on mastering the platform’s affiliate program, LIVE Shopping capabilities, and building authentic partnerships with creators. The most successful TikTok Shop sellers think like media companies first and product companies second.

The Multi-Platform Advantage

Despite these differences, Canopy’s multi-channel experts have seen tremendous success with brands that strategically diversify across all three platforms. Amazon provides steady, high-intent traffic and mature infrastructure. Walmart captures value-conscious shoppers and offers less competition. TikTok Shop excels at discovery-based, impulse-driven purchases and reaching younger demographics.

The key is avoiding a copy-paste approach. At Canopy Management, we’ve built specialized teams for each platform, recognizing that excellence on Amazon doesn’t automatically translate to TikTok or Walmart success.

For brands ready to maximize their e-commerce potential across this trifecta, we offer tailored strategies that leverage the unique strengths of each platform while maintaining consistent brand messaging and operational efficiency.

Remember, it’s not about being everywhere. It’s about being everywhere strategically, with platform-specific optimization that turns the complexities of multi-channel selling into your competitive advantage.

Ready to take your brand to the next level across all three platforms? Our team of former Amazon executives, multi-million dollar sellers, and award-winning experts are ready to help. Because in today’s complex e-commerce landscape, you don’t need another agency. You need a partner.

Canopy Management is a full-service marketing agency for Amazon, Walmart, and TikTok sellers. Our team consists of multi-million dollar, omni-channel entrepreneurs, industry leaders, and award-winning experts. 

Frequently Asked Questions: Multi-Platform E-commerce Success

Is it necessary to sell on all three platforms (Amazon, Walmart, TikTok Shop)?

Not necessarily. While diversification can significantly reduce business risk, each platform requires specific resources and expertise. We recommend beginning with the platform that best aligns with your target audience and product type, then expanding strategically. Many of our most successful partners started with Amazon, built operational excellence there, and then expanded to Walmart and TikTok Shop as their brands grew. The key is having a platform-specific strategy rather than using a one-size-fits-all approach.

How do customer expectations differ across these marketplaces?

Amazon customers typically prioritize reliability, reviews, and Prime shipping. They’re often comparison shopping and researching extensively before purchase. Walmart shoppers tend to be more value-conscious and respond well to competitive pricing and bundle offers. TikTok Shop customers are discovery-driven, making more impulsive purchases based on creator recommendations and trending products. Understanding these behavioral differences is crucial for optimizing your approach on each platform.

What’s the biggest mistake sellers make when expanding to multiple platforms?

The most common mistake we see is simply copying listings verbatim across platforms without considering the unique requirements and audience behaviors of each marketplace. What works brilliantly on Amazon may perform poorly on TikTok Shop without significant adaptation. Each platform has its own search algorithm, content guidelines, and customer expectations. Successful multi-platform selling requires tailored optimization for each marketplace while maintaining consistent brand positioning.

How important is video content for each platform?

Video has different levels of importance across platforms. On Amazon, video enhances listings but isn’t essential for most categories (though this is changing rapidly with Premium A+ Content). For Walmart, video content provides a competitive advantage as fewer sellers utilize rich media features. On TikTok Shop, video isn’t just important—it’s the primary medium. Short-form video is the foundation of the entire platform, making high-quality, engaging video content absolutely essential for TikTok Shop success.

How do pricing strategies need to change across platforms?

Pricing strategy should be platform-specific. Amazon’s algorithm factors in price competitiveness, but brand strength can sometimes overcome slight price premiums. Walmart explicitly includes pricing in its Listing Quality Score, making competitive pricing more directly tied to visibility. TikTok Shop customers often make impulse purchases based on perceived value rather than extensive price comparison, sometimes allowing for higher margins if the value proposition is clearly communicated. We recommend platform-specific pricing strategies that account for these differences while maintaining overall brand integrity.

What metrics should I track to measure success across different platforms?

While standard e-commerce KPIs like conversion rate and ROAS remain important across all platforms, each marketplace has unique metrics worth monitoring:

• For Amazon: Focus on organic ranking improvements, Brand Analytics share of voice, and New-to-Brand customer acquisition.
• For Walmart: Monitor your Listing Quality Score, Pro Seller status metrics, and customer repeat purchase rate.
• For TikTok Shop: Track video engagement rates, creator partnership performance, and product virality (how quickly products sell out after featured content).

Our reporting dashboard at Canopy Management provides customized metrics for each platform while also giving you a holistic view of cross-platform performance.

How do inventory management strategies differ between these platforms?

Amazon’s fulfillment network (FBA) requires longer lead times but offers the advantage of Prime eligibility. Walmart’s fulfillment program (WFS) has more stringent acceptance criteria but can significantly boost visibility. TikTok Shop requires agility to respond to sudden viral demand spikes that can occur when a product unexpectedly trends. Successful multi-platform sellers develop sophisticated inventory forecasting systems that account for these platform-specific behaviors while optimizing overall inventory efficiency.

How can small brands compete against larger competitors on these platforms?

Each platform offers unique opportunities for smaller brands:

• On Amazon, niche specialization and superior customer service can help smaller brands carve out profitable market segments.
• Walmart Marketplace still has significantly less competition than Amazon in many categories, creating opportunities for smaller brands to gain visibility.
• TikTok Shop’s algorithm focuses more on content quality and engagement than seller size, allowing small brands with authentic, creative content to achieve viral success against much larger competitors.

We’ve helped numerous small brands leverage these dynamics to achieve significant growth despite limited initial resources.

What’s the typical timeline for seeing results from platform optimization?

Amazon optimization typically shows measurable improvements within 30-45 days, with more substantial results over 90+ days as the algorithm adjusts. Walmart optimization often shows faster initial results (sometimes within 2-3 weeks) due to less competition, but sustained growth requires consistent optimization. TikTok Shop can produce extremely rapid results—sometimes overnight virality—but also requires persistent content creation to maintain momentum. At Canopy Management, we set realistic expectations with customized timelines based on your specific category, competition level, and starting position.

Do I need separate teams to manage each platform?

While there can be operational efficiencies in having team members who understand your brand across platforms, the specialized knowledge required for each marketplace typically necessitates some level of platform-specific expertise. At Canopy Management, our teams are structured to provide specialized expertise for each platform while maintaining seamless communication and consistent brand strategy across your entire e-commerce ecosystem. This allows you to leverage platform-specific opportunities without creating operational silos.

How does Canopy Management approach multi-platform strategy?

Our approach begins with a comprehensive audit of your current presence and potential across each platform. We then develop customized strategies that leverage the unique strengths of each marketplace while maintaining operational efficiency. Our specialized teams provide platform-specific optimization, content creation, and advertising management, all coordinated through a central strategy team that ensures consistent brand positioning and cross-platform synergies.

With over $3.21 billion in revenue managed and an average 84% year-over-year profit growth for our partners, our multi-platform expertise has helped brands of all sizes achieve sustainable success across Amazon, Walmart, and TikTok Shop.